RADAR LOGIC RPX Quantitative Analytics
IRS Subchapter S & FICA Tax Optimization

2026–2027 LLC vs. S-Corp Tax Savings Calculator

Model your exact federal self-employment (SE) and FICA payroll tax savings when electing S-Corporation status (IRS Form 2553) versus operating as a single-member Sole Proprietorship or default LLC.






Estimated Net Annual S-Corp Savings
+$9,828 / yr
Default LLC Self-Employment Tax (15.3% Eff.)
$22,607
S-Corp W-2 FICA Payroll Tax
$11,016
FICA Tax Eliminated on K-1 Distribution
+$11,591
S-Corp K-1 Distribution (SE-Tax Free)
$80,692
Est. Sec. 199A QBI Deduction (20% Pass-Through)
$16,138 Deduction

FICA Tax Saved: 49%
Remaining S-Corp FICA: 51%

How the S-Corporation Election Reduces Self-Employment Taxes

By default, a single-member Limited Liability Company (LLC) is taxed by the IRS as a disregarded entity (Sole Proprietorship) on Schedule C. That means 92.35% of your entire net business profit is subject to the 15.3% Self-Employment (SE) tax (12.4% Social Security up to the annual OASDI wage cap plus 2.9% uncapped Medicare tax).

When an LLC files IRS Form 2553 to elect S-Corporation tax treatment, business profits are bifurcated into two streams: a Reasonable W-2 Officer Salary (subject to standard 15.3% FICA payroll taxes) and Shareholder K-1 Distributions (which are exempt from Social Security and Medicare payroll taxes).

Tax Attribute Default Single-Member LLC (Schedule C) LLC Taxed as S-Corporation (Form 1120-S)
15.3% FICA / SE Tax Base Applies to 92.35% of all net business profit Applies only to W-2 Reasonable Salary; K-1 distributions are exempt
Payroll & Tax Filings Simple Schedule C attached to Form 1040 Requires W-2 payroll runs, quarterly Form 941, and separate Form 1120-S
Ideal Net Profit Breakeven Under $65,000 annual net profit $75,000+ annual net profit (where FICA savings exceed payroll/CPA overhead)

Frequently Asked Questions (LLC vs. S-Corp Election)

What does the IRS consider a “Reasonable Salary” for an S-Corp owner?

Under IRS guidelines, shareholder-employees must pay themselves market-rate compensation commensurate with their duties, industry, experience, and time devoted to the business before taking tax-free K-1 distributions. While many service businesses model a 40% to 50% salary-to-profit ratio as a preliminary benchmark, reasonable compensation should be substantiated using Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) wage data.

Does paying a lower W-2 salary reduce my Section 199A QBI Deduction?

Yes. The 20% Qualified Business Income (QBI) deduction applies only to the net pass-through K-1 distribution, not your W-2 wages. However, for high earners above the IRS statutory phase-out thresholds, having sufficient W-2 wages is required to unlock the full QBI deduction.

Tax & Accounting Disclaimer: Radar Logic is not a CPA firm or tax attorney. All figures generated by this calculator are estimates for educational planning. Consult a licensed Certified Public Accountant (CPA) or Enrolled Agent before filing IRS Form 2553 or setting officer compensation.