RADAR LOGIC RPX Quantitative Analytics
Housing Economics & Capital Allocation

US Rent vs. Buy & Net Wealth Accumulation Calculator (2026–2027)

Compare the full economic cost of buying a primary residence—including mortgage amortization, property taxes, maintenance, and selling friction—against renting a comparable property and investing your liquid capital.








7-Year Net Wealth Verdict
Buying Wins by +$31,420
Monthly Mortgage (P&I)
$2,217 / mo
Total Monthly Ownership Outflow (w/ Tax & Maint.)
$3,005 / mo
Projected Home Value at Horizon
$600,154
Buyer Net Proceeds (After Loan Payoff & 6% Closing)
$242,890
Renter Portfolio (Down Payment + Cash-Flow Saved)
$211,470

Buyer Net Equity: 53%
Renter Portfolio: 47%

How the Radar Logic Rent vs. Buy Model Evaluates True Wealth

Most basic mortgage calculators compare only monthly principal and interest against monthly rent. That approach ignores three critical quantitative variables: unrecoverable ownership costs (property taxes, homeowners insurance, HOA/maintenance, and upfront/selling closing costs), principal amortization velocity, and the opportunity cost of equity tied up in the down payment.

Cost Component Homebuyer Impact Renter Impact Model Assumption
Upfront Capital Down payment + 2.5% buyer closing costs locked in property equity Invested in diversified index portfolio earning compound market returns User-selected Down Payment % & Investment Return %
Monthly Unrecoverable Cost Mortgage interest + Property Tax (1.25%/yr) + Insurance/Maintenance (0.85%/yr) Monthly lease payment escalating at 3.0% annual rent inflation 2.1% combined annual tax/maintenance carrying cost
Exit Transaction Friction 6.0% seller agent commissions & transfer taxes upon sale Zero exit commission on liquid brokerage assets Deducted from terminal home value at horizon

Frequently Asked Questions (Rent vs. Buy Parity)

Why does renting often beat buying over holding periods under 4 years?

Buying and selling residential real estate involves roughly 8% to 9% in combined round-trip transaction costs (2%–3% buyer closing costs at purchase plus 5%–6% agent commissions and transfer taxes at sale). In the first 3 to 4 years of a 30-year mortgage, most of your monthly payment goes toward interest rather than principal reduction, meaning appreciation alone must overcome transaction friction.

What is the 5% Rule for Rent vs. Buy decisions?

The 5% rule estimates the annual unrecoverable cost of homeownership as roughly 5% of the home’s value (comprising ~1% property taxes, ~1% maintenance/insurance, and ~3% net cost of capital). Dividing target home price by 12 and multiplying by 5% gives a quick monthly breakeven rent benchmark.

Financial & Editorial Disclaimer: This calculator models hypothetical real estate and investment scenarios for informational purposes only and does not constitute mortgage lending, tax, or investment advice.